Hello dear
Welcome To Renna's Pizza
Renna's Pizza, located in Neptune Beach, FL, offers a delightful culinary experience that brings a touch of New York pizza charm to the Sunshine State. Customers rave about the quick service and the inviting atmosphere, underscored by a friendly staff. The standout dishes include the extra-large buffalo chicken pizza and the delectable garlic cheese bread, both praised for their balance of flavors and quality ingredients. With a clean environment and an enticing rewards program, Renna's Pizza has quickly become a beloved spot for locals. Whether dining in or grabbing a slice to-go, you’re sure to leave satisfied and eager for more.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Tossed
Philly Steak
Specialty Calzone
Cheese Calzone
About
Renna's Pizza
Welcome to Renna's Pizza, where the essence of authentic Italian flavors meets the breezy coastal charm of Neptune Beach, Florida. Nestled at 630 Atlantic Blvd Suite 15, this haven for pizza aficionados is quickly making a name for itself as a go-to spot for delicious, quality pizza. With just a quick call to +1 904-372-4736, you can indulge in a delightful array of mouth-watering pizza offerings.
Renna's Pizza stands out not just for its tantalizing menu but also for its warm and inviting atmosphere. First-time customers rave about their experiences, with Alyssa Skaggs noting the speedy service she received—her extra-large buffalo chicken and medium pepperoni pizzas arrived fresh within 20 minutes of ordering. The friendly staff, highlighted by their Tuesday shift member, adds to the overall welcoming vibe, ensuring that each visit feels special.
The menu at Renna's is a true celebration of pizza craftsmanship. Customers like D’Ambrosio, Michelle have found a slice of home here, claiming the pizza tastes just like the classic offerings from New York. Whether you're craving a hefty slice or a whole pie, Renna's has something to appease every palate. From the savory garlic cheese bread to the praised lasagna—upgraded with Greek salad and garlic knots—there’s no shortage of dishes to explore.
Quality is paramount at Renna's, and the cleanliness of the establishment impresses many, including Bridget Portune, who looks forward to enjoying dinner on the patio in the wintertime. With its well-kept environment and attentive service, every visit promises a relaxing experience.
No meal would be complete without acknowledging the many recommendations from devoted customers like Ray Len, who visits twice a week. His pro tip to savor pizza by the slice and to elevate the meal with some fantastic garlic knots is one that shouldn't be missed. At Renna's, each bite is a celebration, capturing the essence of traditional pizza culture while reflecting the community's character.
In conclusion, Renna's Pizza is more than just a restaurant; it’s a community gathering spot that serves joy by the slice. If you find yourself in Neptune Beach, don’t miss the chance to visit this pizza gem that promises not only delicious food but a heartwarming atmosphere. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Renna's Pizza will surely leave you with cravings for more.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This was my first time trying Renna’s pizza and I’ll definitely be back to the Neptune beach location. I ordered an extra large buffalo chicken pizza and a medium pepperoni pizza both were done in about 20 minutes. Tuesday guy at the register was very friendly and the place was clean. They also have a reward card. The pizza was amazing. ”
“ Now check this out. I’m gonna keep some details redacted because I don’t want them to get flooded with requests but listen to this. I’m a big fan of a style of pizza that’s not from around here. When I walked in to place my order I asked ... ”
“ So good! The pizza and garlic cheese bread are delicious! The staff was very nice. It's super clean and new. Looking forward to dinner on the patio this winter! ”
“ Amazing pizza and service!!! Lived in NY all my life and the only pizza spot I found that tastes like NY pizza!!! ”
“ Pizza by the slice is excellent. So is the lasagna.... pro tip: upgrade the salad w the lasagna to a Greek salad and upgrade the garlic bread to the garlic knots. I eat here twice a week. ”
“ The person that took our order was nice and friendly. The food was great and worth the drive from orange park just so we could get a Sicilian pizza, so thank you for making it worth the drive. Atmosphere was great lots of inside seating, as well as outside seating. Go here they have Sicilian. ”
“ Friendly and respectful service from Tyler. Great atmosphere and quick service, gave a choice of beers on tap while you wait for a to go order. Great food!!! ”
“ Food is always AMAZING!!! Fast friendly service always with a smile. Thanks, Tyler! ”